Skip to content

Technology and money in plain English · Since 2012

Finance
Guide

Car Negative Equity: Edmunds Says Underwater Trade-Ins Owe $7,107, and How to Check Yours

Edmunds says 29.1% of financed trade-ins carried negative equity in Q3 2026. How to check yours, what rolling it into a new loan costs, and what the FTC and CFPB advise.

Key facts

  • Edmunds says 29.1% of financed trade-ins had negative equity in Q3 2026, averaging $7,107 owed. As of
  • Buyers who rolled it over financed an average $57,235 at 8.1% APR, with a $952 monthly payment (Edmunds). As of
  • The FTC says a dealer promising to pay off a loan while folding the cost into the new loan is illegal. As of
  • The CFPB says to confirm the old loan was paid off, checking with the old lender about a week after signing. As of
In this story8 sections
Rows of new SUVs at a dealership lot, where negative equity can follow a trade-in
Image: Luke Miller / Pexels

Last checked . Picks are based on the prices, rates, fees and terms each provider publishes, checked at the source. We never rank products by commission. See how we’re funded.

Negative equity means a car loan balance is higher than the car’s market value. Edmunds says 29.1% of trade-ins tied to a financed purchase in the third quarter of 2026 carried it, with an average of $7,107 owed. This guide covers how to check yours, what rolling it into a new loan adds, and what the FTC and CFPB say to do.

  • The latest Edmunds numbers
  • A three-step check of what you owe and what the car is worth
  • What rolling the gap into a new loan costs
  • Options, gap coverage and dealer red flags

Dollar examples marked as The Jolt Journal’s own are arithmetic, not agency or Edmunds figures. Details are as of November 16, 2026. This is not financial advice.

Negative equity on a car: the numbers at a glance

The figures below come from Edmunds’ third-quarter 2026 report, published October 20, 2026.

Advertisement
MeasureQ3 2026
Trade-ins with negative equity29.1% (30.9% in Q1 2026; 28.1% in Q3 2025)
Average negative equity$7,107
Prepandemic average (2016 to 2019)Typically $5,000 to $5,500
Average amount financed by buyers who roll it over$57,235
Average monthly payment for those buyers$952
Average APR8.1%
Estimated lifetime interest$16,610
Those loans running longer than 72 months91.2%

Edmunds says these buyers financed about $12,600 more than the average new-vehicle buyer. They paid $165 more a month and nearly $6,700 more in lifetime interest. In early 2022, 14.7% of trade-ins were underwater, with an average deficit under $4,300, per the same report.

How to check your negative equity

Couple shaking hands with a car salesman while weighing a trade-in offer
Photo: Vitaly Gariev / Pexels

Three steps give a usable number in a day.

  1. Get a payoff quote from the lender. The CFPB says the payoff can differ from the statement balance because of how interest is calculated, late fees or other charges.
  2. Estimate the car’s value. The FTC names NADA Guides, Edmunds and Kelley Blue Book. The CFPB adds Consumer Reports and local classified ads.
  3. Get offers from several dealers. The CFPB says to collect quotes and negotiate.

Then subtract. The FTC’s own example shows the math.

LineFTC example
Car’s value$15,000
Amount owed$18,000
Equity (value minus owed)-$3,000

A dealer’s offer can land below an online estimate. The Jolt Journal suggests running the subtraction with the lowest real offer, since that is the number a trade-in will use. Owners preparing a car for sale can also use the site’s guide to checking car recalls by VIN.

What rolling negative equity into a new loan costs

The FTC says a dealer that “pays off” the old loan may simply add the shortfall to the new loan, take it from the down payment, or both. The new loan then carries interest on the shortfall plus the price of the next car.

The next table uses the $7,107 average and Edmunds’ 8.1% average APR. It isolates the cost of the rolled-over amount alone. The rows are The Jolt Journal’s arithmetic from a standard loan formula, rounded to the dollar, and ignore taxes and fees.

Loan termAdded monthly paymentAdded interest
60 months$144$1,560
72 months$125$1,890
84 months$111$2,228

The longer term shrinks the monthly bump but raises the interest. It also keeps the buyer in negative equity longer. The FTC advises choosing the shortest term affordable when the balance is rolled over. Edmunds says buyers who must replace a car soon should weigh total financing cost, not just the monthly payment.

The site’s report on car dealer fees and the FTC’s Greenway order lists checks to run before signing.

Options for negative equity when you owe more than the car is worth

OptionWhat the agencies or Edmunds say
WaitThe FTC says to wait until the current car has positive equity. Extra principal-only payments can speed that up.
Pay down firstEdmunds suggests keeping the car longer or paying down the loan before trading, when circumstances allow.
Sell it yourselfThe FTC says a private sale may beat a dealer’s offer. The loan must still be paid off.
Trade in and roll it overThe FTC says to ask how the balance will be handled, read the contract and get oral promises in writing.
Add a down paymentThe FTC’s financing guide says a down payment can reduce the total cost.

The CFPB adds one more check. If the car is worth more than the loan, repay the old loan fully first and check for a prepayment penalty.

Does gap coverage help with negative equity?

Gap coverage addresses a different problem than trade-in negative equity. A CFPB blog post describes it as covering the difference between what is owed and what insurance pays after a theft or total loss.

  • Optional: buyers are not required to purchase it and can decline.
  • Where it is sold: dealers, some insurers (check the existing policy first) and some banks or credit unions.
  • Dealer price: a plan sold by the dealer is added to the amount financed, so it accrues interest.
  • Limits: some plans do not cover negative equity rolled over from a trade-in, and a missed payment can void coverage.
  • Timing: it is only needed while more is owed than the car is worth.

The site’s report on falling car insurance prices covers a renewal-time moment to ask about existing coverage.

Dealer promises and what to confirm after signing

A car key handed from one person to another after a vehicle sale
Photo: Antoni Shkraba / Pexels

The FTC says dealer promises to pay off a loan may be misleading. It says that if a dealer promises a payoff but folds the cost into the new loan, that is illegal, and it asks consumers to report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

The CFPB lists these follow-up steps:

  1. Make sure any promised payoff is not included in the financing or final contract.
  2. Confirm the old loan is fully paid off once the new agreement is final.
  3. Wait about one week, then call the old lender to verify.
  4. If it is not paid off, contact the new lender.
  5. If that fails, file a complaint with the FTC or CFPB, or contact the state attorney general.

What is not known

  • How a specific lender or dealer will treat negative equity. Payoff figures and offers vary by lender and by day.
  • Whether a given gap plan covers rolled-over negative equity. The contract decides.
  • Who is in Edmunds’ sample. The figures describe trade-ins tied to financed purchases, not every car owner.
  • Where the fourth-quarter figures land. Edmunds had not published them as of November 16, 2026.

Editor’s take

Editor’s take: The $7,107 average hides a wide range. The number that matters is the owner’s own: the payoff quote minus the lowest real offer. Small negative equity may be cheaper to pay in cash than to finance for seven years. A large balance may call for a few months of extra principal payments before shopping. A dealer, a credit union and an independent buyer can each price the same car, so it helps to collect all three first.

This article is for general information on negative equity, based on FTC and CFPB guidance and Edmunds’ third-quarter 2026 report as of November 16, 2026. It is not financial or legal advice. Figures and rules may change.

See something that needs fixing? Report an error

This article is for information only and is not financial advice.

Get The Jolt Journal in your inbox

The day’s top stories in tech, finance and AI, picked by our editors. Free.

Up next

Keep reading

Add The Jolt Journal as a preferred source on Google

Add The Jolt Journal to your Home Screen to get alerts

  • 95 Stories published

Jolt Journal Finance covers interest rates, markets, mortgages, personal finance and fintech, with a focus on what changes mean for your money. Our finance coverage explains; it is not personal investment advice.

Covers

Most Popular

More in Finance

See all

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Breaking-news alerts

We’ll send a notification to this device when a big story breaks. Choose what you want, then allow notifications when your browser asks. You can change this or turn alerts off any time.

Send me